Questions to ask before trusting an image match
Use these questions to evaluate claims made by a vendor, a platform, or a product reviewer. They are based on published guidance from NIST and U.S. authorities. FaceIndex has not conducted interviews for this edition.
- What task was evaluated?
A one-to-one comparison and a one-to-many search have different error measures. Ask which test was actually run and who controlled the reference set.
- What happens to your upload?
Ask which service processes the image, how long it keeps it, and whether a removal request covers the probe, thumbnails, derived data, or all three.
- What changes after a match?
Before filing a report, write down what the result establishes and what independent evidence you still need. Confirm the actual public link through an authorized route.
Read the methods and the recovery guidance
Ask for an answer you can verify
When an expert says a service can “find you online,” start by separating three possible claims: it found a copy of one image, it returned a resemblance, or it verified an account holder’s identity. Ask them to name the claim, the reference data, and an observable result that would support it. A useful answer names conditions in which the method fails.
- For vision researchers
- “What happens to the number of incorrect candidates when the gallery gets larger?” Look for the tested gallery size, the comparison threshold, and how absent identities were counted. If they only cite a one-to-one test, ask whether a gallery search was evaluated separately. NIST’s one-to-many evaluation.
- For privacy and trust teams
- “Which system receives the upload, and what is the deletion route?” Ask whether the company is describing its interface or its upstream processor. Clarify what happens to thumbnails, logs, or derived templates if those are used.
- For investigators
- “What independent evidence would change your conclusion?” A transaction reference or information from an official account can be more relevant than a photo. Ask how a person can share that evidence with the reviewer while leaving out unrelated private details.
Worked example: a similar profile photo
A search result shows a photo resembling a friend’s public headshot next to a fundraising account. This is an illustrative example. The first question is whether the campaign’s actual destination claims to be managed by the friend. If the link goes to an organization, contact the organization through an independently verified channel. Preserve the public claim and the URL if there is a reason to report it. A resemblance alone supplies no basis for contacting or accusing the person shown in a result.
When reviewing a tool or a claim, record the date, the original source, the precise statement, and what evidence would verify or contradict it. This gives someone else a way to check your notes later instead of relying on a summary or a screenshot without context.

